Skip to content
Skip to content

Independent e-magazine

the OUTSPOKEN digest

Verity Beat Tom Cruise's Digger at the Box Office, Despite a 34 Percent Score From Critics

Anne Hathaway's Colleen Hoover adaptation took $32.6 million in North America, while Cruise's costly Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu satire managed $8 million and fifth place, his weakest opening in 19 years.

Outspoken Digest Culture Desk

Monday, October 5, 2026/2 min read

Actress Anne Hathaway, the star of Verity, at a press conference in February 2023, a file photograph and not a still from the film
Photo: Harald Krichel via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

The weekend's counter-programming match ended in a rout. Gold Derby's weekend report said Amazon MGM's Verity, adapted from Colleen Hoover's bestselling thriller, opened to $32.6 million to take first place in North America, while Warner Bros.' Digger collapsed to $8 million and fifth place. That is Tom Cruise's lowest opening in 19 years.

Verity beat the forecast

The thriller, directed by Michael Showalter, stars Anne Hathaway as a celebrated author who cannot finish her series after an accident, Dakota Johnson as the writer hired to complete it, and Josh Hartnett as the husband. Gold Derby reported a further $30 million overseas for a $62.5 million global start, the second-biggest worldwide launch for a Hoover film, behind It Ends With Us. Variety had projected a debut of around $35 million. It is Hathaway's third number one opening this year, after The Devil Wears Prada 2 and The Odyssey.

The film was not a critical success. Yahoo Entertainment's review roundup found Hathaway the brightest spot in several reviews, with Mashable's Kristy Puchko calling her "regal and ruthless," while Variety's Guy Lodge dismissed the film as a "flat-footed dud." Gold Derby gave it a 34 percent Rotten Tomatoes rating and a C+ CinemaScore. Because it reportedly cost $40 million to make, it is already set to turn a profit.

Digger's costly weekend

Digger, from the director Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu, took $12 million overseas for a $20 million global debut, against a budget reported at $160 million to $180 million, plus about $100 million in marketing, according to Gold Derby. Audiences gave it the same C+ CinemaScore. Variety had suggested it could open with around $12 million in North America, so it came in below even that.

The rest of the chart

Zach Cregger's Resident Evil reboot held second place with $12.5 million in its third weekend, which brings its total to $124.8 million domestically and $215 million worldwide on a $75 million budget. Heart of the Beast took third with $11 million, a drop of just 45 percent in its second week.

What it says about the audience

The result suggests that audiences, at least for now, will turn out for a recognisable book and a recognisable cast at a modest price, even when critics are lukewarm, and that a hugely expensive star vehicle needs more than a famous name. For Hathaway, whose year has included blockbusters and a run of five releases, Verity is the last of 2026's films. For Amazon MGM, the C+ will matter less than the profit. For Warner Bros., the attention now turns to the second weekend, where the true size of the hole will become clear.

Published in The Outspoken Digest

Editorial desk

Outspoken Digest Culture Desk

Reports for The Outspoken Digest across Lifestyle, Design, Fashion, Latest Trends.

Newsletter

The Digest, in your inbox

One edition, sent when it is ready. No noise, and your address is never passed on.

We send a confirmation first. One click to leave, always.

Share this story

the OUTSPOKEN digest

Beyond boundaries. Independent stories on technology, culture, and the trends shaping how we live.